Great, except for the main zipper
I first got the XL because I was between chest sizes, but I ended up in a Large that's still comfy. Would be good to also have cinches at the waist/hip opening to minimize updrafts. The exchange process was pretty painless. It kills the wind and rain as good as anything I've used. I liked the drawstring holders as a detail because they don't whip around in the wind and take an eye out! My only whinge is that the main zipper in the front (with O'Neill printed on it) was misaligned and very difficult to operate. It split open at the base twice yesterday and I'm begrudgingly thinking of sending it for replacement and refund.
Rated 3 out of 5
Rated 1 on a scale of minus 2 to 2, where minus 2 is Fits small, 0 is True to size and 2 is Fits Large